top of page
Search

What's Analog Horror and why is it so effective?

  • Apr 11, 2025
  • 6 min read

Updated: May 28, 2025



Who is human test from The Mandela Catalogue
Who is human test from The Mandela Catalogue




If you've never heard of Analog Horror or experienced it for yourself, my friend you are missing out on nostalgic comforting but twisted stories and scares. Analog horror has been a hidden gem on the internet for years and I've seen a lot of analog horror content myself but in all honesty, I never knew how to describe it to other people who asked me what it was and what made it so unique. So to explain the significance and artistry of analog horror, I created this piece to hopefully break it down a bit more, explain why it's terrifying and loved by many horror fans online, and give you some recommendations for the best analog horror out there.


By now, you are probably familiar with the cult horror classic The Blair Witch Project from 1999 that sort of launched the "Found-footage" genre of horror films. Found-footage films are films that are made using pretty average and cheap equipment in an amateur filming style to imitate that feeling that someone just like you could have made what you just watched and that while you don't know the person, they may or may not be around to tell the tale anymore and the footage you watched is all that's left of them and the story. This genre was popularized initially by the Blair Witch Project but later catapulted into fame by the Paranormal Activity film series and other films like Grave Encounters, V/H/S, Rec, and one of my personal favorite underrated films The Last Exorcism.


What does this have to do with Analog horror though? Well, analog horror was inspired by the found footage genre and the home-video-like quality of the footage. These films typically aren't filmed on Panasonic cameras in sound stages but rather in old homes and properties using a Canon or old film camera which makes it feel like something you could do which in turn would mean that these experiences and horrifying topics could happen to you too. That's why found-footage horror and analog horror are so similar and so effective in creating an uneasy and terrifying atmosphere for their viewers.


What makes horror analog? By definition: Analog horror is created by or deriving inspiration from the use of primitive technology.


Analog horror is different from found footage in a few critical aspects one being that analog horror is typically based on some nostalgic specific property or topic like old toys, video games, universal experiences like holidays, sleepovers, news broadcasts, and VHS tapes, and it tries to invoke some sort of familiarity with the topic rather than just the way something is filmed like found-footage does. The story is often the main focus of analog horror while found footage is typically focused on the way the story is captured through camera work and sound. These analog horror films and videos tend to not rely heavily on jump-scares (which Y'all know I love when films and videos don't rely on jump-scares to be a "horror" film) but rather the psychological aspect of horror through unsettling visuals, uncanny valley effects and voices, and grain. The true test of analog horror is if you continue to think about it long after it's finished and you second-guess a few aspects of your early childhood or even your day-to-day life now when everything's different. The effect of VHS tapes and older media is just as effective with slight and sudden shifts causing the temporary feeling of uncertainty and uneasiness as the visuals quickly distort and glitch until they appear normal again. But while most people assume there's dust on the VHS or it wasn't wound properly, you never know the exact reason for the distortion and glitching happening on your screen which leans into that feeling of uncertainty and the fear of the unknown no matter how slight and temporary it may be.


The analog horror genre technically started to gain more momentum in 2019 but for me, I remember the first experience with anything analog-horror-like was with this one video game that went semi-viral on YouTube in 2016-2017 and it's called Tattle Tail. This game terrified me because it centered around Fubries and if you don't know what Furbies are, you're probably lucky! I had a Furby when I was younger and I loved it, during the day and when I was actively using it. My Furby had a tendency to start talking and make noises randomly at night and react to things that weren't happening and this scared me so much that I put it in an old toy chest in my basement every night and buried it underneath old blankets to stop it from talking to me at night. All that to say, Tattle Tail scared me because it plays off of that fear that I had and centers around Christmas time, which I love Christmas a lot so when horror properties play off of the holy-ness and comforting nature of Christmas it gets me freaked out so much and I love it, but it had some elements of VHS tapes and old night-vision technology incorporated in it which are all things I experienced in my childhood briefly. To be clear I am currently 20 years old and I did experience the tail end of the VHS and Furby prime era very vividly. Analog horror isn't just for films and videos, as seen in the video game Tattle Tail that I just mentioned but analog horror games that are effective are harder to come by.

Videos and films are much more effective in that analog experience and that's why they are way more popular and terrifying. I was introduced to the term "Analog horror" referring to video format online through my favorite podcast CreepCast by YouTube creators Papa Meat and Wendigoon (not sponsored just love these guys) I had never put it together that this was a genre and I had seen a clip or two on social media floating around once or twice but in their limited series on the podcast, that I need them to bring back, CreepTV, they dissected a lot of internet analog horror and I that got me interested in just what analog horror was and why it was so scary to me and them.


Something like the Backrooms uses the fear that most humans have and that's being forgotten. The use of VHS tapes and footage similar to that medium is often used since VHS and home video formats have largely been forgotten in this digital age and that invokes the real fear of temporary relevance and the fear of being forgotten or overlooked.


The first piece of analog horror that may pop into your mind after reading all of this is the Mandela Catalogue because the style is so iconic to not only the property but to the analog genre in general. The use of just photos being altered progressively is so simple but effectively terrifying with the story being put together through the use of images and images alone in a few of the main sequences but the horror is all psychological which can be a hit or miss for some people. While there are plenty of videos and moving images to compliment the photo-only sequences, the videos would never hold up without the context and build-up of the image-only portions of the series. So many ideas come into play here and get deep about humanity and being a true human which I believe analog horror is the best medium for invoking such disturbing and existential thoughts in a horror fashion. This is something large studio releases or even indie films in a typical film format can't do as effectively as analog horror does.


Overall, analog horror is really amazing at dissecting human fears and emotions in a more psychological way through storytelling and experience rather than just relying on stark visuals and jump scares. The use of few visual scares makes the times when they are used, much more impactful and supportive to the story at large and leaves a lasting impact on the viewer. The sound design, visual grain, uncanny valley voices, and visual through graphics or video, all combine into some of the most high-quality horror available to humanity right now.


Don't worry, this won't be the last time I bring up Analog horror by any means. Upon researching this topic more and more I found myself creating a list of analog horror series that I plan to watch and review for you all and analyze so more analog horror will be coming very soon! Until then, I'll be leaving the links to some of the content I mentioned in this post for you to watch and digest before I review and analyze it.




Content referenced:


Comments

bottom of page